xauaudit

← Blog · Signals

“TP1 hit” is not a winning trade

XAU Audit4 min read

TP1Partial targetsStop loss

XAU AUDIT · SIGNALS TP1 HIT, THEN A LOSS 1 in 3 585 of 1,748 signals that reached TP1 lost money 0.1 lot · broker execution · demo account
Article contents (3)
  1. How a signal really plays out
  2. What our records show
  3. What to look at instead

“TP1 hit ✅” is the post you see most on Telegram gold channels. It sounds like a win. Often it isn’t: in our records, one in three signals that reached the first target ended with a net loss.

How a signal really plays out

A typical gold signal has an entry, a stop loss and three to five targets. Followed to the letter, it becomes one order per target, each with the same stop. When the price touches TP1, only the first order closes in profit. The others stay open, and if gold turns around they all close at the stop.

SELL XAUUSD 4,032 · SL 4,040 · TP1 4,028 · TP2 4,024 · TP3 4,020 · TP4 4,012 TP1 hit order 1 +4 $ reversal orders 2–4 stopped at 4,040 −8 $ × 3 Result: “TP1 hit ✅” on the channel, −20 $ per 1 oz on your account

The channel posts the target. The three stops usually go unmentioned.

What our records show

We execute every signal this way at a broker: one order per target, the channel’s own stop, nothing closed by hand. In the signals recorded in our channel histories, from late August to 23 October 2026:

1,748signals reached at least the first target
585of them still ended with a net loss
421signals hit the stop without touching any target

Out of 2,169 signals, only 1,025 reached every target. The rest are where the money is actually made or lost, and they rarely make it into the channel’s posts.

What to look at instead

That is what the dashboard shows for every channel: the net of every order the broker closed, signal by signal.

Today’s results don’t guarantee tomorrow’s. Channels win and lose. These numbers describe what already happened on our demo account; they are not advice and not a promise.

All results from our demo account at the broker, shown for 0.1 lot per order, euro account. Every signal is executed as published: one order per target, the channel’s own stop, closed by the broker. Results are hypothetical for real trading: spread, slippage, timing and size can change them. Channel names are not shown here; subscribers see them in the dashboard.

See every channel’s record, signal by signal.

Start the free 10-minute trial

More articles